SPOILER ALERT: The following contains spoilers for The Rainmaker Season 2, Episode 6.
Merle Dandridge has brought a different energy to The Rainmaker Season 2. Her character Amanda Vonn is still the unquestioned antagonist of the USA series, but there’s something more going on with her that viewers are still trying to put their finger on. And the way Amanda is able to handle people—from Sarah Plankmore to her quirky paralegal Megan Grenier to Irish gangsters—should be studied.
With the action now shifting to the Irish courts and seemingly a home-field advantage for Amanda’s clients, TVBrittanyF.com sat down with Merle to discuss what makes her character tick. What sets Amanda apart from all of the powerful women Merle has played in the past, from Chief Natasha Ross on Station 19 to Persephone in Hadestown? And how does Amanda truly see the people around her—are they just tools, or does she actually care about Megan and Sarah?
“Everything always starts on the page for me, and Amanda just seemed to sing in a way,” Merle reflected on coming aboard The Rainmaker for Season 2. “I knew that I had a way into her—but there was another element that I felt was going to be a challenge for me, and I think it was her stillness. There’s so many times, especially in the beginning of the season, where [the script] says something like ‘Amanda doesn’t react’ or ‘Amanda says nothing,’ and in those silences, she seems to say so much more. I was interested in the challenge. Being a theater actor, the text had always motivated anything that I did before, and in this there was a stillness that I needed to explore.”
It’s that stillness and silence that makes Amanda so unnerving to the audience. Her predecessor Leo Drummond could be—and still is—very calm, but viewers always had an idea of exactly how he felt. In Amanda’s case, there are so many scenes where fans want that reaction. They want to know what she’s planning, or what she’s thinking when Megan says her next randomly cutting remark. At the outset, Amanda felt so much like Leo because she held her cards so close to the vest; the audience couldn’t define her. Now as the season goes on, they’re starting to realize how many layers there are to Amanda Vonn… if she decides to reveal them.
Of course, the most obvious is the history between Amanda and Leo. It’s been referenced several times throughout The Rainmaker Season 2, such as when Leo recommended Sarah to Amanda (albeit with somewhat of a backward compliment). Watching Season 1 was part of Merle’s process for stepping into the role—not only for herself as an actor, but as opposition research for Amanda.
“Anything that happened in the first season, Amanda would be very well versed in, especially if she was pursuing any kind of connectivity or opposition to any of these attorneys. The fact that she knows enough and investigated enough to pursue Sarah with such rigor tells you everything,” she said. “But for Merle’s part, it was important for me to know everything that Amanda knows. Anything that had taken place before, you better believe Amanda has not only knows well, but has probably analyzed beyond the events that had already transgressed.”
As for whether or not people will learn more about exactly how Amanda knows Leo, or even who Amanda was before this? Well, that might have to be the long game. “You are being drip fed little bits and pieces about how they interact, and what their relationship might be and how they feel about Sarah,” Merle told us. “You already know that they have a history—that they have a shared trust in some way. That’s a funny word to use with characters like those. But there’s a lot to mine there.”

What’s very clear is that like Leo, Amanda is an imposing force in the courtroom. Their approaches are different—Leo seemed to enjoy putting pressure on Rudy Baylor and company, whereas Amanda’s stillness makes her more emotionally detached. She’s focused solely on achieving her objective. But those courtroom scenes, with their complex language and performative dialogue, are a perfect fit for Merle’s extensive theater background. She’s played Mary Magdalene in Jesus Christ Superstar, the title character in Aida, and Persephone in Hadestown all on Broadway, and reprised her role as Spamalot‘s Lady of the Lake at the Hollywood Bowl. So did any of that assist her in crafting Amanda’s courtroom presence?
“The court kind of felt like my arena because behind closed doors, Amanda is plotting. She is operating at a level and with an intelligence that, sometimes I feel like Merle is playing catch up with that,” Merle commented, “but being on the stage of a trial, suddenly a different mode kicked in, and her theatricality became a little bit easier for me.”
The audience is certainly used to seeing Merle Dandridge in a position of authority. Back on the small screen, she played Chief Ross on Station 19 for three seasons. Yet she also appeared as Marlene, leader of the Fireflies, in The Last of Us. She ran an entire news network guest-starring as Diana in the Murphy Brown sequel, and helped lead an entire congregation as Grace in Greenleaf. And TV viewers may not remember that she was initially cast as the battalion chief on Chicago Fire. Yet Amanda Vonn’s power has proven to be on a whole other level, which is another one of the ways portraying her delightfully challenged Merle.
“Amanda might be the first character—as far as the the personality of the character and what that character is able to do—that intimidated me as a person. If I were to to encounter Amanda Vonn in the wild, she might intimidate me,” Merle explained. “So there was a level of giving over to her, and allowing myself to sit in her shoes, that I think really informed and taught me. That’s a big testament to the writers, that they created a world and they created a person that is so enigmatic that it took me a minute to be able to feel like I can really walk in this girl’s stilettos.
“I knew who she was. I knew how she got where she was. I knew what tools and what traumas had informed how sharp that she is. I knew her level of education. But for me to actually take that mantle on was a different animal,” she continued. “[With] Chicago Fire, I got the opportunity to train with the Chicago Fire Department for weeks, so when Chief Ross and Station 19 came along, I already knew what to do. She was already in my DNA. I had lived with that, and I had lived with the fire department… But there’s something about Amanda that her enigmatic nature eluded me at first, and then we became fast friends. And I have to say, it has been a delicious banquet to play.”

Speaking of friends, Amanda’s dynamic with her paralegal Megan is the quirkiest part of The Rainmaker Season 2. It’s undoubtedly the show’s comic relief, because Megan seems to lack not only a filter but certain social skills. That makes it perplexing as to how she ended up at Amanda’s right hand, as the two would appear to be polar opposites. We asked Merle what it’s like working opposite actor Libby Kay, who plays Megan, and what Amanda actually thinks of Megan. Why does she keep such a loose cannon around when everything else in her professional world is so deliberate?
“With Libby, because we have such a love and an affection, I have to say it kind of bled into our real life a little bit. She’s so sweet and so constantly hugging and just such a bright light in the room,” Merle told us. “The doing of it was so much fun for us. She was game for all of my side looks, and obviously she just brings an absolute light to the screen.
“Amanda actually secretly—maybe you see some of that on the screen—really delights in Megan, and really sees something there. The fact that Megan is saying, I don’t want to be a lawyer… Amanda knows that she has the ability to even exceed where Amanda is, and yet she chooses this kind of alternative route, and to just screw around. She’s having fun with life, but it feels evident and it feels imminent that when Megan decides to put the rubber to the road, she’s going to run us all over.
“I think that kind of reeled-back tiger is one of the reasons why we really love her so much, and because you see that she’s got so much heart. [She’s] so much fun to play opposite of.”
Yet can the same be said for Amanda’s relationship with Sarah Plankmore? In Episode 6, Amanda’s clients are surprised that Sarah is listed as her co-counsel, to which Amanda blithely describes Sarah as “a tool” in her arsenal. Sarah knows that her new boss only hired her in the first place as a weapon to use against Rudy. On the surface, their dynamic couldn’t possibly appear to be any more transactional—but is it really? Is Sarah still “building trust,” as she tells her handler, or has Amanda already made up her mind?
“That’s the ultimate question, isn’t it? It’s how is Amanda perceiving Sarah?” Merle said, pointing out that the answer can be found in Amanda herself. “In this male-dominated world, and her being the female partner in this old institution, you even see the evidence of how she is trying to change the world. The office has a femininity even, with the way it’s decorated. You can see that she has asserted herself. So trying to pull up other women, I believe is important to Amanda, even as cold as she may come off.
“I think Amanda is always looking for many uses, many roads in, and many outcomes. So, yes, in this particular scenario, Sarah is a tool to Amanda, and Sarah turns out to show so much more than she expected would come from a young attorney. There’s so much more there than she immediately believed there to be, and the fact that Leo endorsed her—there’s definitely something that’s more intriguing there. As far as affection can happen, I’ll let the viewer decide that. But for my part, I believe that Sarah has been a cream that has risen to the top for Amanda, and I think she really wants to look out for that.”

Those layered character dynamics are an example of what has come to set Amanda Vonn apart in the world of The Rainmaker. There’s no doubt that she’s the season’s antagonist, and the person whom the audience is hoping for Rudy to get through to find justice for all of the abused children, both past and present. But to distill Amanda down to just the villain would be a disservice. There’s simply too much that the audience doesn’t know about her, from the specific nature of her connection to Leo, to why she’d throw her lot in with criminals. Episode 6 begins to hint at that, but Merle believes that Amanda isn’t completely detached—that there’s a humanity viewers haven’t seen yet.
“There’s a lot to say about where I feel like Amanda’s Achilles heels are, and how she has become, quote-unquote, ‘ruthless.’ Is she ruthless, or is she surviving? Is she as cold and calculated as people might believe? I don’t think so,” she explained. “One part of it is that I am the actor, so I’m deeply empathetic to Amanda Vonn, and I’m deeply empathetic to where she came from, the circumstances that made her build these iron walls around her. She is so infallible—very, very rarely shaken. And when she is shaken, in which she is taken off guard, when something does surprise her, how does she react, and why?… I deeply feel that she has been through some horribly refining fires that created the person that she is now, and my hope is that the audience gets to see that part of her, and where her limits might lie.
“It was so important to me to to bring her to life in a way that was full,” she said. “I think you can immediately see somebody who is very reserved and a strong presence, and sometimes very sharp-tongued, and assume they’re one thing. And there is so much to this woman, [with] how she can advocate or cut you off at the knees when it needs to happen. Whereas on the surface it might seem cold and heartless, I would challenge the viewer to look a little bit closer and see what might actually be motivating those things.”
Whether or not viewers ever get the full story of Amanda Vonn’s past, there is plenty of moral ambiguity to explore in the present. She is calculating and she can seem distant, but her speech in the Season 2 premiere was spelling out her modus operandi. She waits for her moment. Obviously that moment from a legal perspective is finding a way to destroy Rudy’s case. But it’s also not off the table that there could be a human moment for Amanda when she is confronted with the totality of what Aughrim and Harrowsgate and the whole enterprise has done. When Rudy completely spells it all out—as he will, because that’s Rudy’s superpower, to elucidate the truth—will she stand her ground? Or could she be like Sarah and her conscience will get the better of her? Only time will tell. But even as a villain, Amanda Vonn has her own statement to make.
“I got to know Amanda and explored her through the lens of Rudy’s story, of the world of The Rainmaker, coupled with an incredible crew in Ireland and extraordinary cast that really made me feel very welcomed. It felt like a great playground to to get to know her,” Merle said. “[She’s] a woman who seems to have this billionaire problem, She’s deeply attracted to people who seem inaccessible—very strong, expensive clients who can seem ruthless, really powerful, who might feel dangerous. It’s like a moth to a flame to her, and it’s almost as if she knows she has the tools and the way to wrap herself—as that razor wrapped in silk—around people and draw them close.
“Ultimately, for my part, for a bigger purpose, because some of these ivory towers are difficult to topple. I think that she believes she has a way in, and and so she may move in nefarious-looking circles,” she concluded. “But why? Why is she in those circles? We need people behind the iron curtain, don’t we? And I think she’s doing that. Is she perfect? Oh my goodness, no. But she is a strong woman doing difficult things, and I hope the audience perceives that she is more than that. She is operating on a higher level.”
The Rainmaker airs Fridays at 10:00 p.m. ET/PT on USA. Photo Credit: Christopher Barr/Courtesy of Versant Media.
Article content is (c)2020-2026 Brittany Frederick and may not be excerpted or reproduced without express written permission by the author. Follow me on Twitter at @BFTVTwtr and on Instagram at @BFTVGram. For story pitches, contact me at tvbrittanyf@yahoo.com.





