Season 2 of Ludwig has proven to be as creative and fun as Season 1 of the David Mitchell-led mystery series. Yet the second season has also felt quite different, thanks to a couple of significant changes. How did the show keep its high standards, while also going off in interesting new directions?
Ahead of the Ludwig Season 2 finale streaming on BritBox, executive producer Kenton Allen joined TVBrittanyF.com to talk about the positive reaction to the show (including an American version in development). He also spoke about adding new cast members to the mix and why Mitchell is so sublime in the role of John “Ludwig” Taylor. Plus, find out which actor he’d like to see appear in future episodes!
Brittany Frederick: The first season of Ludwig was a massive hit. What was it like for you as producers to see such an overwhelmingly positive reaction?
Kenton Allen: It’s really special. It’s always surprising when something you have spent an inordinate amount of time doing connects with an audience. This show seemed to connect in ways that we hoped would happen. But it’s always a surprise when the reaction is so positive to a show, and I certainly think in the UK, it was about a number of things.
It was about David Mitchell sort of becoming almost a national treasure, in terms of his ascendancy for audiences through Peep Show and various other shows in the UK, and then the simplicity but brilliance of [Ludwig creator] Mark Brotherhood’s script, and then all that stuff that we do all coalescing into a show that people seem to like.
Did that acclaim then increase the pressure when it came to developing Ludwig Season 2? Or did it have any positive effect on this season?
Not really, no, because from the get-go, we had quite a clear idea of what would happen to the character between Season 1 and Season 2—that he would stop pretending to be his brother at the end of the first season, and that in Season 2 he would become a sort of consultant.
I guess it just what it helped with was when I when phoning up Stephen Merchant saying do you want to come and play a murdering snooker player, he knew what the show was and knew that the show was good. It wasn’t that first season problem where nobody knows what the hell you’re doing. It’s just words on a page. [Laughs.]
But I don’t think we changed our approach at all because we just wanted to tell the the stories that we had, and we certainly didn’t have any more money. In television, the more successful you are doesn’t mean the more money you get; it often means the opposite. So we just carried on being true to the characters and embracing what Mark wanted to do, and spent a lot of time trying to think of clever ways to kill people.
The show’s caught on so much that ABC is already working on an American adaptation called Rabbit. What does that mean to you?
We’re involved in that; that’s them and us. Myself and my brother and David Mitchell are non-writing executive producers. But that’s good. That doesn’t happen every day, so [we’re] excited about that.

Aside from the consultant part, Ludwig Season 2 also involves two new additions in Ben Ashenden’s Ethan Cole and Rumi Sutton’s Caitlin Sullivan. That’s a big change relatively early in the show. How did you navigate that shift, and develop the characters of Cole and Sullivan to make them as interesting as their predecessors?
That was not deliberate. Unlike American TV shows, we are not in the position to option actors in the UK, and we didn’t know we got a second season until the first season had gone out. We managed to cast Gerran Howell, who is brilliant, and he got noticed by some people that make a show called The Pitt. I don’t know whether you’ve heard of it. [Laughs.] They both [Howell and Izuka Hoyle] got picked up on different shows, and we didn’t have them optioned, and then they weren’t available. So that was force majeure rather than creative brilliance. We had to replace them, and we wish them well.
We sit in a room and we talk about what people are like and what good stories would be. Ben Asherton’s character thinks Ludwig’s an idiot and can’t believe that somebody with no qualifications is allowed to come in and play detective, and then decides that he’s probably a spy. That all just came out of talking with Mark Brotherhood and kicking ideas around and seeing what would be fun—and what would be real as well. What would you think if you got thrust into that situation: you’ve newly joined a new detective force, and you’re told there’s a crime scene consultant. What the hell’s that? That’s a made-up thing. If you’re at all curious, you think there’s something weird going on there.
Ludwig Season 2 still revolves around David and Anna Maxwell Martin, both of whom are incredible fixtures on British television. They’re doing some of their best work; what do you think it is about the show that fits them so well?
For David, I think it is the culmination of a huge body of work, predominantly in half-hour comedy, in Peep Show and Back—a show we made that nobody watched. [He’s done] a lot of half-hour comedy work, and then stepping up as the lead in a one-hour procedural.
And then with Anna, she’s a brilliant actress. She likes to play interesting characters. This on the page seemed interesting to her, and unbeknownst to us, they have that unbelievable thing that you can’t predict, which is chemistry. They have an amazing, amazing on-screen chemistry, and that you only get to learn about when you start shooting. There’s some educated guessing about what they’ll be like together, but that chemistry has flourished from Season 1 to Season 2. We’re now halfway through Season 3, and there’s an awful lot of chemistry there.
Both of them also have the ability—Anna in particular—to turn on a sixpence and to navigate the quite difficult tonal shifts that these shows often present actors, which is to move from flippancy and irreverence and no-consequence playfulness into quite big and serious issues within their lives, in quite a British way. The British are very good at being flippant about massive things, as if it doesn’t really matter that your husband’s missing or somebody’s dead. [Laughs.] I’m sure you’ve heard of the British stiff upper lip. There’s an element of that in there, but it’s also they’re both brilliant actors. They find the humor in in the situation, but they can also navigate their way through to the more emotionally serious or dramatically serious elements with great skill.
There’s just a chemistry there, magic there that happens when they come together, but nothing that one could have predicted, apart from you’ve got two brilliant individuals and two brilliant actors, so hopefully that will deliver something that is more than the sum of its parts.
The British are also particularly great at these locked-room mysteries. So in terms of the crimes themselves, do you have any favorite Ludwig plots?
In Season 2, my favorite episode is the death by sushi [Episode 5] because I, like Ludwig, love a sushi conveyor belt. So I love that episode, and I love the snooker episode [Episode 4] because it involves a contraption, and all men of any age love a contraption. It involves a contraption that shoots something into somebody in an unexpected way.
Is there any idea that you and Mark wanted to do, but it just didn’t work out in the end? Any murders that got left on the proverbial cutting room floor?
No, because anything that approaches that is probably in the bottom drawer and requires some more thinking. Nothing’s impossible. We just need to be clever enough to work out how it’s possible.
You mentioned Stephen Merchant earlier, and part of the fun of doing these TV crime shows is the guests who get to play in the sandbox. What has it been like to have the level of guest talent on Ludwig, and how do you approach having other recognizable names in your cast?
We don’t write for specific actors; we write the character, and then we have a brilliant casting director called Amy Hubbard who reads it and then suggests actors for it. We like if they’ve got some kind of comic legacy in their [history], just in terms of the universe of the show.
Stephen playing against type—playing an incredibly unpleasant, arrogant, cheating, lying, murdering snooker player—felt delicious to us and delicious to him. It’s trying to find casting where actors are feeling that they can do something they haven’t done before. That’s always fun for an actor and fun for us.
But we always write the characters and then think about the casting and not the other way around. The other way round sort of leads to trouble. You’ve got to be careful that the most high-profile actor can’t always be the murderer. Otherwise, the audience will see that coming a mile off. There has to be some smoke and mirrors there.
Is there anyone you think would be a particularly good fit for the unique tone and world of Ludwig?
I personally would love Tony Shalhoub to be in an episode, because he’s Monk. I think Tony would be amazing. We’ve got David Suchet in our Christmas special, and obviously David was Poirot, and I suppose we could have fun going through the rolodex of great iconic TV detectives and find spaces for them. [Laughs.] But Tony Shalhoub is a brilliant actor. He was Monk, and it’d be interesting to find a character that he could have fun with that wasn’t Monk, but that fans of this genre would appreciate that he was in our show.
Ludwig streams Tuesdays on BritBox. Photo Credit: Courtesy of BritBox.
Article content is (c)2020-2026 Brittany Frederick and may not be excerpted or reproduced without express written permission by the author. Follow me on Twitter at @BFTVTwtr and on Instagram at @BFTVGram. For story pitches, contact me at tvbrittanyf@yahoo.com.





