SPOILER ALERT AND WARNING: The following contains spoilers for Maigret Season 2, Episode 5. It also contains discussion of suicide.

It’s hard to believe that Maigret Season 2 is almost over. “The Yellow Dog, Part 1” is the first half of the final case of the season, and so naturally the PBS Masterpiece series is bringing its personal and professional threads together. The best way to do that is to drop Maigret into another story involving the social elite, and indeed this episode has a lot of classic plot elements.

“The Yellow Dog, Part 1” involves another high-profile murder, and the death of businessman Albert Mostaguen has all the hallmarks TV crime drama fans would expect. The victim belongs to an elite club, along with three other friends who are all wealthy businessmen with influence in Paris. Of course, the key to solving Mostaguen’s killing has to do with something sinister in their past. There’s a very “haves and have nots” angle to this particular whodunit, which in turn opens the door for Maigret to think about his upbringing in Saint-Fiacre, and that brings the case of the week in line with the ongoing subplot about Maigret and Louise’s future. One can see showrunner Patrick Harbinson efficiently connecting all the dots.

These familiar themes mean that there aren’t as many genuine shocks in the episode. Even when another of Mostaguen’s associates is killed, it’s not much of a surprise—that’s how these kinds of stories typically go, and the plot needs another victim to keep the investigation going into Part 2. Fans can essentially follow along with Maigret as he moves through the early phases of the case, because they know what he needs to do. The reveal that the tragic past involves a people-smuggling operation adds another, sadder layer to the story, yet viewers who’ve watched enough crime dramas may have been able to guess that angle from the red handprints just as Maigret does. The lack of huge reveals doesn’t take away from the episode, though, because the case is more of a framework to push the character development that’s been happening throughout the season to its tipping points.

Réka Fruzsina Szabó as Young Sophie de Saint Fiacre and Grundberg Anders Olaf as Young Maigret in Maigret season 2 episode 5. (Photo Credit: Gabor Kotschy/Courtesy of Playground Entertainment and PBS Masterpiece.)
Réka Fruzsina Szabó as Young Sophie de Saint Fiacre and Grundberg Anders Olaf as Young Maigret in Maigret season 2 episode 5. (Photo Credit: Gabor Kotschy/Courtesy of Playground Entertainment and PBS Masterpiece.)

An early scene involves Maigret coming home early and overhearing Louise remarking that she wants to “make a break,” which circles around to the discussion that the couple have had about leaving Paris and going back to Saint-Fiacre. Louise later tells Maigret she called to check on the estate and that Maurice would like him to become the estate manager. Of course, the audience knows that Maigret leaving Paris would make it incredibly hard for the show to continue (this isn’t Midsomer Murders), so there’s also not a ton of suspense necessarily generated on the subject. Rather, it’s what the idea provokes in Maigret that makes this important. He’s once again having to face his past, including another brief flashback.

Meanwhile, the most interesting scene involves newcomer Bonfils, who randomly has a meltdown after Mostaguen’s friends go on an expected rant about the police. This is Maigret‘s most cliche scene followed by its most intriguing one. Even knowing that they’re speaking in the heat of the moment after another of their friends has died, it’s preposterous how the businessmen think Maigret should magically solve the case, and viewers have seen moments like this before on so many other shows. But in the wake of that, Alex Bhat is great as viewers finally hear Bonfils use his voice, albeit in a misplaced way. He’s been relatively quiet and timid, yet in his moment of cracking, the audience gets to see Bonfils as a character of his own, not just as Cavre’s former right-hand man. This is a wonderful episode for Bhat, between that and the scene in which Bonfils is the first to welcome Lucas back to help with some research.

Speaking of Cavre, Rob Kazinsky also gets a very human moment here, when Lucas overhears Cavre speaking to his partner Marie—and the conversation doesn’t sound good. It’s easy for Maigret viewers to think of Cavre as a single-minded antagonist, particularly this season as his scenes have leaned into that idea. But “The Yellow Dog, Part 1” has that reminder that Cavre, too, is a human being. It will be interesting to see how much Harbinson reveals about the context of that phone call, or even if Cavre and Maigret genuinely end up on the same side again, now that Cavre has been seconded to the investigation.

The same cannot be said for Guichard, who pops up for two scenes, one with Maigret that’s exposition and one with Kernavel. While Kernavel finally tells Guichard what he needs to hear, it feels like Guichard just pops up in her office every time he wants to complain about Maigret. The prosecutor ought to start charging him for therapy. Will his arc end in Episode 6 since he seems to be mostly a roadblock for Maigret? Or could Season 3—as there ought to be a Season 3—actually explore their shared past further and give viewers some concrete proof that there was a time these two characters liked each other?

“The Yellow Dog, Part 1” is clearly laying the foundation to resolve Maigret’s crisis of faith, his future with the police department and the shakeup within his team. The case around which it’s built is not the most exciting story that Harbinson has ever adapted, but it serves its purpose in both keeping the audience engaged and having plot elements that are relevant to the bigger picture of Season 2. The true test of this episode will be how the next one wraps it all up, and hopefully Maigret will get the peace that he deserves.

Maigret airs Sundays at 9:00 p.m. ET/PT on PBS Masterpiece, and is streaming on the PBS App and PBS Masterpiece on Prime Video. Photo Credit: Gabor Kotschy/Courtesy of Playground Entertainment and PBS Masterpiece.

Article content is (c)2020-2026 Brittany Frederick and may not be excerpted or reproduced without express written permission by the author. Follow me on Twitter at @BFTVTwtr and on Instagram at @BFTVGram. For story pitches, contact me at tvbrittanyf@yahoo.com.

Trending